5 Top Moments from 'True Crime Obsessed' Live on Broadway

A retired theater podcaster, not-a-mother, and a Tony Award winner walk onto a stage... what ensues? True Crime Obsessed Live on Broadway! Below, we showcase our top five moments from TCO on Broadway, moments we will relive over and over again.


Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle raise hands up and strike a pose on the Broadway stage.
Rebecca J. Michelson Photography

"Okay, Bye Bye!"

As you all heard, the TCO team re-wrote the lyrics of "Cell Block Tango" from the musical, Chicago, to match a few inside jokes you may have recognized. For those of you who couldn't catch the show in person, here is a preview of some of the lyrics:

Tom (it's chaos down here)

Liza (Where's my club)

Bears Gonna Bear

Super Hot Husbands

Nancy Grace

and Robert Durst


Two Words: Kick Line

TCO choreographer Josh Buscher and director Bob Bartley created the most spectacular staging at the Hayes Theater for our cast. We are still reeling over the grand finale, a straight up KICK LINE with GP and PH at the center. Missed it? Don't worry, our friends at Obsessed with Disappeared uploaded the moment on Twitter.


"I am f***ing Keith Morrison."

Okay, these new slideshow edits featured onstage were next level. In case you are new to TCO live shows, Patrick and Gillian feature these exclusive images in each of their live shows. You can catch more exclusive PH and GP chosen slides on tour this spring.


Wigs, Wigs, Wigs

"They had it coming..." You knew what you were getting yourself into with two theater kids, right? We could not pass up a few quick changes throughout the show, including hilarious wigs that match some of the TCO personalities you have come to know and love.


All of You

We would have never been able to make our debut as the first podcast to perform on Broadway if it were not for all of you, listeners. Since 2017, you have joined hosts Gillian Pensavalle and Patrick Hinds for weekly episodes, laughs, and true crime coverage. We love each and every one of you!


See Gillian and Patrick on tour this Spring 2022.